The Gumbygate Scandal: China’s Haibao versus America’s Gumby

24 Flares Twitter 1 Facebook 23 Reddit 0 Google+ 0 Pin It Share 0 PinExt The Gumbygate Scandal: Chinas Haibao versus Americas Gumby picture 24 Flares ×

The Shanghai Expo is a grandiose world fair being held on the banks of the Huangu River in Shanghai, China, from May 1 up until October 31. According to Wikipedia, it will be the largest and most expensive Expo ever held. As of late April, it appears that it may also be the most controversial.

At the center of the controversy is the Shanghai World Expo’s mascot, Haibao, who many claim bears a striking resemblance to the US-based, animated superstar known as Gumby.

 The Gumbygate Scandal: Chinas Haibao versus Americas Gumby picture

The issue first came to light on April 23, when during a Shanghai Expo press conference, NPR foreign correspondent Louisa Lim accused Haibao’s creator, Wu Yongjian, of blatantly plagiarizing Gumby. According to Lim, the similarities between Haibao and Gumby— shape, eyes, hair, etc.—are far too many to be mere coincidence.

Haibao Gumby Similarities Chart The Gumbygate Scandal: Chinas Haibao versus Americas Gumby picture

In addition, some bloggers speculate that Wu may have first discovered Gumby from watching Growing Pains, a late-80s/early-90s US sitcom that later blossomed throughout China. Featured smack dab in the middle of main character Ben Seaver’s room is none other than Gumby himself.

Growing Pains Gumby The Gumbygate Scandal: Chinas Haibao versus Americas Gumby picture

According to Jonathan Adams at AOL news, however, Wu “strongly denied plagiarism, saying he had not seen the Gumby character before conceiving Haibao.” He even cited the possibility of filing legal charges against all the accusers, especially Lim.

Expo spokesman Xu Wei also shared his input, saying to NPR, “Haibao was unveiled a long time ago. If anyone thinks that their copyright has been violated, that person would already have used legal means to address this by now.”

The irony is that Wu apparently also plagiarized from Xinxiang/Henan HAIBAO Electrical Appliance Company, whose logo is a near-identical match to Haibo. According to the Associated Press, however, company officials are delighted at the free publicity. “Frankly, it was a surprise for us, and the biggest-ever advertising for free,” said an unnamed spokesman.

Xinxiang Henan Appliance Company The Gumbygate Scandal: Chinas Haibao versus Americas Gumby picture

Regardless, it looks like Wu has a lot of explaining to do!

Below is a more in-depth look at the Gumbygate Scandal. Unfortunately for our English speakers, it is entirely in Chinese.

0 The Gumbygate Scandal: Chinas Haibao versus Americas Gumby picture

Links (1 2 3 4)

 The Gumbygate Scandal: Chinas Haibao versus Americas Gumby picture

V Saxena

I am a 28-year-old heterosexual male hailing from Raleigh, North Carolina. I was raised in America and intend to bring up my children as proud Americans because I am defined by neither my past nor the color of my skin, but rather by the path I choose to take in…
« Go to post archive
8 comments
George
George

I have to say, it is not same or a copy. The same thing is that they are both cartoon figures. If you believe, you can say Mickey mouse if copied from M duck.

aml
aml

i don't think it's plagiarised; the design is too simple -- it could have been dreamed up by numerous people. It's like saying that many ancient civilisations plagiarised a swastika-like symbol form each other - the indians, the celts, the incans all had it. but it's just a cross with bent arms. likewise both gumby and haibao are just solid colour rectangles with arms and legs

Kok
Kok

looks nothing alike.

Twisted_Colour
Twisted_Colour

Haibo's shape is based upon the Chinese character for ocean/sea - 海 hai3.

Mike
Mike

i really don't see the resemblance from gumby and haibo. if you really think about anyone can create those "mascot" because all you have to do is take a shape and give it arms, legs, and a face. In fact, i can take a circle give it arms, legs, and face (along with a few accessories) and people will probably sue to for "plagiarizing" mr. potato head

Kite
Kite

Yes I'll sue you for plagiarizing Pacman. LOL

VBob
VBob

I had a feeling about that, but I was in a hurry and had no way to confirm. Thank you for your input!

eileen.
eileen.

the videas in japanese....